YOUR
Search

    30.01.2025

    Procurement and labour: Decree Law No. 19 of 2024


    1. Procurement: among economy, society and poor work

    Procurement is a crucial sector for the economy and business strategies, but it has also sadly hit the headlines as a possible breeding ground for unfair practices, up to and including outright labour exploitation. The year 2024 saw the action of various institutions to counter such phenomena. In particular the judiciary (with the Court of Milan at the forefront) stood out for its initiatives, involving multiple sectors (especially fashion and logistics).

    Investigations by Public Prosecutor's offices have uncovered phenomena in which companies that were the final beneficiaries of subcontracting chains were ultimately aware or unaware beneficiaries of labour exploitation schemes, not only in economically vulnerable sectors, but also in high-margin production sectors and with no geographical distinction across the country.

    In the context of said renewed attention to the topic - which, to tell the truth, has been characterised for some time now by great regulatory vitality (suffice it to think of the countless amendments to the joint and several liability regime) - there arises, most recently, the action of lawmakers with Decree-Law No. 19 of 2024.

     

    2. The reintroduction of criminal liability

    Decree Law No. 19 of 2 March 2024, which was published in Official Gazette No. 52 of 2 March 2024 and came into force on the same day, has introduced significant changes in the field of procurement. Subsequently, it was converted into law, with amendments, through Law No. 56 of 29 April 2024, which was published in Official Gazette No. 102 of 29 April 2024 and came into force on 30 April 2024.

    One of the most significant novelties introduced by the Decree Law is the reintroduction of criminal liability for infringements related to illegal employment of labour. The penalties, which were abolished or mitigated with the decriminalisation of 2016, are now reinforced to fight phenomena such as the abusive supply of labour, the unlawful use of labour and unlawful posting.

    Said legislative choice aims to limit unfair and anti-competitive practices, while at the same time offering greater protection to workers even in situations where there is no labour exploitation, but where there are simulation phenomena or, in any case, the exercise of protected activities, such as staff leasing, without the necessary authorisations. 

     

    3. In detail: penalties

    The legislation establishes a detailed penalty system for specific breaches. 

    Here is a summary:

    a) Unauthorised staff leasing

    • For the provider: imprisonment of up to one month or a fine of 60 Euro per day/worker, with aggravating circumstances in the case of minors.
    • For users: a fine of 50 euro per day/worker, also applicable if the permitted limits are exceeded.

    b) Non-genuine procurement and posting

    • Imprisonment of up to one month or fine of 60 Euro per day/worker for both parties.

    c) Fraudulent staff leasing

    • Imprisonment of up to 3 months and/or fine of 100 Euro per day/worker for both parties.

    d) Unauthorised mediation

    • Imprisonment of up to 6 months and fine of between 1,500 and 7,000 Euro.

    e) Unauthorised search and selection of personnel or outplacement

    • Imprisonment of up to 3 months and fine of between 900 and 4,500 Euro.

    4. Guarantees on minimum economic and regulatory treatment

    In addition, a general rule has been introduced which states that “Personnel employed in the procurement of works or services and in subcontracting shall be entitled to an economic and regulatory treatment that is on the whole not lower than that provided for by the national and local collective bargaining agreement entered into by the trade unions of workers and employers that are comparatively more representative at national level, applied in the sector and for the area strictly related to the activity that is the subject of procurement and subcontracting”.

    The provision is not easy to apply given the difficulty of defining the concept of comparatively most representative trade union, due to the variety and uncertainty of the criteria used. 

    Moreover, also the reference to the collective bargaining agreement applied by sector and area represents a different concept from the concept used in other regulatory sources, with correlated doubts as to interpretation and application. Needless to say that, if one thinks of the “sector”, there are several national collective bargaining agreements (even considering those that are actually representative) that cover the same activities and could therefore be taken as a reference.

     

    5. A fairer market?

    Will the new rules succeed in improving working conditions and promoting a more transparent and truly competitive market? To answer the question, it will be necessary to evaluate the concrete effects of the application of the rules outlined above by the judiciary and inspection bodies.

    In the meantime, the debate remains open. 

    Number of Partners grows in ADVANT Nctm with 4 new promotions
    ADVANT Nctm strengthens its corporate structure with the appointment of Roberto …
    Read more
    The "Jobs Act" is again under scrutiny by the Constitutional Court: reinstatement will be granted in all cases of null dismissals
    The Constitutional Court, in the judgment no. 22/2024, declared the illegitimacy of Article 2(1) of Legislative Decree no. 23 of 4 March 2015, only as to the word “expressly”. This provision was held to be…
    Read more
    Dismissal of a teacher with multiple sclerosis for absolute and permanent inability to perform the duties is null and void as discriminatory
    The Court of Milan, Labour Section (judgment no. 4276/2023), recently declared null and void, as discriminatory, the dismissal ordered for alleged absolute and permanent inability to perform the duties of …
    Read more
    Labour Decree
    The following is the in-depth discussion by our Labor and Industrial Relations Department on the following topics: Case Law: Law no. 104/1992: the burden of care must be flexible The waiver of i…
    Read more
    Labour Decree
    Decree Law No. 48 of 4 May 2023 (the so-called “Labour Decree”), containing “Urgent measures for social inclusion and access to the world of work”, published in the Official Gazette No. 103 of 4 May 2023 a…
    Read more
    Dismissal for exceeding the grace period and disability Case law on disability and indirect discrimination in determining the grace period
    A new case law approach is noteworthy, which sees dismissal  of workers with disabilities by reason of exceeding the grace period as a form of indirect discrimination. Such approach is based on the prin…
    Read more
    Post-pandemic Smart Working; the guidelines of the Protocol of 7 December 2021
    On 7 December 2021, on the initiative of the Ministry of Labour and Social Policies, the major Employers’ Associations and Unions signed the National Protocol on Agile Work. The purpose of the document …
    Read more
    Nctm Studio Legale joins the Employment Law Alliance (ELA), the world’s largest network of employment law firms
    Nctm Studio Legale has been selected as the Italian Member of the Employment Law Alliance (ELA), the world’s largest network of lawyers specialising in employment law, labour relations and immigration, rec…
    Read more